Factory Owner:
As beautiful as Lake Baikal is, the protection of it cannot be at the price of industrialization in Russia. The Paper and Pulp Mill located next to the Lake plays an important role in Russia’s industry. Over the past decades, the paper industry has boomed, and paper is in high demand. We cannot just stop creating paper; that would be impractical. Russia's economy and the global economy would suffer major cutbacks. The recent closing of the factory due to “pollution concerns” has left approximately 800 people without jobs. It is unfair to take jobs from these people based on an issue that isn't actually a problem. Many of our workers are lower class citizens who count on their pay to provide food and housing for their families. The health of the Lake is important, but there is not a real ecological problem even facing the lake. For this reason, the Paper and Pulp Mill should remain open and active. However, a new disposal system is necessary and should be created. It's possible to find another location to dump factory waste. ![]() |
| Paper Mill |
Local Russian Boy:
Since I was a little boy, I have heard folk songs and stories about the beautiful enigma that is Lake Baikal. I remember eating a bowl of goulash as my Babushka shared folk stories about the lake with my little sister and me. The Lake is more than just a large body of water; it is a symbol of rich Russian culture. I have enjoyed memorable summers near the lake -- camping, fishing, hiking, and more. My father was a local fisherman who sold fish in our village, Listvyanka. Most locals are fishermen or artisans. I still live in the same village I grew up in, and the Lake remains at the cornerstone of the village's culture. But in recent years, the Lake has been changing. The ice on the lake is no longer as thick as it used to be, which I understand is very bad for the majestic Baikal seal, as well as the overall ecology of the Lake. Not to mention, the ice is simply beautiful. Winter is never complete without coming to visit and admire the stunning turquoise ice caps. I would be devastated to see anything about this remarkable lake change, and I hope that Russians and people from all over the world will help to stop the pollution that is harming our lake. Lake Baikal is a source of pride for us. We have legends and stories about extraordinary creatures in the lake, as well as numerous folk songs about its beauty. It is the cornerstone of our culture, and Russia would not be the same without it.
| A local Russian boy living on the shore of Lake Baikal. |
To listen to one of the folk songs go to The Holy Baikal.
Victor Gulevich, Diver:
I am a rescue diver with the Baikal Search and Rescue Center and I have been witnessing the negative impacts of climate change and ecological negligence. My work requires me to dive into the lake to remove cars that have crashed in the lake. I work Monday to Friday, but in recent years I have continued diving on Saturdays in order to withdraw trash from the bottom of the lake. The most common trash I have seen is empty bottles. It is frustrating to see so much trash in the lake, because it's polluting the lake's organisms. Over the years, I have also noticed the rising surface water temperatures, an impact of climate change. I hope that it's not too late to save the lake from all the human and natural stressors.
![]() |
| Car Found in Lake Baikal |
On Friday
February 14, 2014, we interviewed Dr. Marianne Moore - an expert on Lake Baikal
and the climate change affecting it. To learn more about Dr. Moore, visit her bio page at Wellesley.
Sofia:
Can you give us any examples of symbiotic relationships in the lake?
Marianne
Moore: The classic example of symbiosis in the lake is between the sponges and
the algae. There is a symbiotic alga that grows inside the sponges. The algae
are providing sugars for the sponges and the sponges are filtering water so
they bring in water laden with nutrients, like nitrogen and phosphorous, that
helps the organisms to grow. The algae are photosynthesizing and excrete sugars
that help to support the sponges. This process is visible to the human eye, but
is poorly studied in Lake Baikal. Symbiotic relationships are not studied that
much in Lake Baikal, but there has been plenty of time for evolution to occur,
so I think that there is much room for more study.
Lake
Baikal is similar to coral reefs, resulting in it having many, many more
symbiotic relationships. There are vents on the floor of Lake Baikal with
chemosynthetic bacteria. Animals contain chemosynthetic bacteria, allowing them
to receive sugars.
S: Can
you explain the food chains in Lake Baikal, and how climate change has
negatively impacted that, especially in regard to the endemic diatoms?
MM: There
haven’t been irreparable effects yet on the food chain. Using long term data
collected by many Russians, we have documented a shift in the composition of
the zooplankton community. Shrimp epischura, a grazer that contributes to high
water clarity of the lake has declined because the surface waters have warmed.
Along with this, daphnia have increased 15 fold or 300% in abundance. The
daphnia feed differently than the epischura, also excreting differently.
Daphnia ties up more in the water column than epischura, and phosphorus is
necessary for phytoplankton growth, and Lake Baikal needs a certain amount of
phytoplankton growth to sustain all the members of the higher up on the food
web, or higher on that food chain. We don’t know yet what the result is going
to be if this continues, but it could mean that there will be less phosphorus
available in the water column for phytoplankton growth
S: What
are some of the more pressing issues involving climate change and the lake?
Where else is the climate change coming from?
MM:
Regarding the pulp mill, I think that’s a red herring now. I don’t think it’s a
serious threat to the lake anymore. It has closed. It’s no longer economically
viable. The owner of that mill can’t make money anymore, and in my opinion,
climate change is one of the greatest threats to this system because climate
change affects the entire lake and the entire watershed, whereas pipe
pollution, which that mill is an example of, has a very localized effect. That
pulp mill has affected a very small portion of this enormous lake. Whereas
climate change has the potential to affect all of it, and there’s no question
about it – the waters have warmed significantly. One of the potential problems
with climate change is shortening the ice cover on Lake Baikal. There are two
groups of organisms that depend heavily on the ice – they have to have that ice
present for reproduction. One of them is the seal, and the other is some of the
endemic diatoms (these are phytoplankton species that are extremely important
in the lake’s food chain). Shortening that ice cover could cause a severe
reduction in the population abundance of the seals because they require that
ice for successful reproduction, and so do those endemic phytoplankton.
S: What
is the point where the algal bloom is too small or too big?
MM: Many
people think that algae are bad, that too much algae clouds the water, creating
oxygen deficits, but what people forget is that algae are necessary to sustain
that food web. You have to have an optimal amount there to sustain the
zooplankton, the epischura, which in turn, feeds the fish and animals, in particular
the seal. It is certainly possible that if that ice starts to thin, those large
endemic diatoms will not remain in the water column – they’ll seep out because
there’s no longer the connective set up with the gross PI. So those large
diatoms, which are extremely important in that food web, seep out, and what
happens is they could be replaced by much smaller phytoplankton species,
species that are so small that epischura can’t feed successfully on them. Then,
you don’t have a way of moving that photosynthetic energy up the food web. In
other words, the amount of energy going all the way up to support the seal
declines, and there are fewer seals. Thinning of the ice could potentially
favor much smaller phytoplankton species that cannot graze sufficiently.
S: Could
this harm the seal in the long run?
MM: Yes,
it could, because of the inefficiency of energy transfer, or food transfer, up
the food web. There’s less food moving up that food chain.
S: Are
there any solutions that might stunt the affect of climate change on the lake?
MM: There
are other human stressors that interact strongly with climate change, and I
think those need to be attacked immediately. It’s very difficult to stop
climate change because it’s a global problem, but there are other stressors.
One of them is the crumbling infrastructure of Russia, by that I mean roads are
in a very poor state in rural Russia, so are railroad tracks. One of these
roads pass very close by the lake, and every day, I think it’s twice a day,
there are many cars carrying Russian oil across the country. With the climate
change, you get a melting of the permafrost, causing the ground to become very
uneven, and that could easily cause a rail disaster, where you’ve got a whole
bunch of oil going into the lake. There are other examples, for example the
pulp mill. Even though the pulp mill was closed, there are enormous silos
containing very strong acids that were used to bleach that paper and many other
chemicals. Those silos are huge, so with the permafrost melting under climate
change, those chemicals could easily end up in the lake. In my opinion, Russia
needs to begin cleaning up these other problems around the lake because they
will become severe problems with climate change. Another example would be the increase
in tourism. There’s unregulated tourism happening particularly along the shore
of the central basin of Baikal Island. There’s unregulated building of tourist
facilities and none of these facilities have sewage treatment – it’s not being
treated and it’s going directly into the lake. With climate change, the
eutrophication would essentially be accelerated for reasons that are hard to
explain.
S: What
is eutrophication?
MM:
Eutrophication is the addition of nutrients that fuel excess phytoplankton
growth, causing dissolved oxygen deficits, and even fish kills in extreme
situations. The lake right now can withstand a certain amount of
eutrophication, but with climate change, the lake is going to become much more
sensitive to it. The waters will become warmer, so the phytoplankton will grow
more rapidly. Now, the phytoplankton have much more nutrients from all that
untreated sewage, but they’re also growing much more rapidly because the
physics of the water columns changes under climate change, resulting in a water
column which is divided up into the upper warmer waters and the lower colder
waters, causing un-contained phytoplankton growth in those upper waters. The
lake will become much more sensitive to that as water temperatures warm. The
local government, the Russian federal government should be proactive and try to
shut down and limit, as much as possible, the excess nutrients from untreated
sewage and the erosion of soil going into the lake.
Reference List
Baikalsk Paper Mill. (n.d.). Retrieved February 18, 2014, from Pacific Environment website:
Kunisue, N. (2012, September 9). Lake Baikal, a pristine natural wonder, that is in danger.
Retrieved February 18, 2014, from The Asahi Shimbun website: http://ajw.asahi.com/article/globe/feature/trans-siberian/AJ201209090021


No comments:
Post a Comment